A $9.3 Billion Category Forecast Misses the Question Walmart Suppliers Need to Answer

Ninety-four million U.S. households now own at least one pet, according to the American Pet Products Association’s 2025 State of the Industry Report. Total U.S. pet industry spending reached $152 billion in 2024, and APPA projects $157 billion for 2025. Pet toys occupy a particular position within that spending: high replacement frequency, strong repeat purchasing, and a product lifecycle governed by wear rather than obsolescence. A February 2026 analysis from Future Market Insights projects the global pet toys market will grow from $4.7 billion to $9.3 billion by 2036, at a 6.9% compound annual growth rate, with chew toys commanding roughly 36% of category revenue and dogs driving approximately 52% of demand.

Encouraging numbers, all of them. They confirm what most pet suppliers already sense: the category is expanding, durability-led formats are winning, and repeat purchase cycles remain intact. But the forecast, like most market-sizing exercises, treats channels as static containers. It reports that specialty pet stores hold about 41% of sales and that online continues to scale. It does not reckon with one particular retailer reshaping the terms on which pet toy suppliers compete for that growth, and doing so faster than most channel forecasts can track.

Walmart has been building its pet infrastructure with unusual specificity over the past 18 months. Pet Services Centers have opened in Georgia and Arizona. Virtual veterinary care, delivered through a Pawp partnership, is now bundled into Walmart+. The Pet Pharmacy has expanded to cover home delivery and in-store pickup. Private-label pet food under the PRO+ brand is competing in the super-premium segment. Meanwhile, Walmart’s ecommerce business posted 27% U.S. growth in Q4 of fiscal year 2026, and its Marketplace had surpassed 200,000 active sellers as of mid-2025, per Walmart’s disclosures at the Let’s Grow Marketplace Seller Summit. Walmart Connect advertising revenue grew 41% in the U.S. during the same quarter (excluding Vizio), per Walmart’s Q4 FY26 earnings release. Advertising and membership fees together accounted for about a third of Walmart’s Q4 operating income, according to the company’s earnings commentary.

Suppliers and sellers working within this system already know the category is growing. The harder question is how Walmart’s evolving infrastructure, incentive structures, and performance expectations reshape what it takes to sell pet toys at scale through the Bentonville retailer.

Walmart Is Treating Pet as a Platform, Not a Department

Most category forecasts frame growth as a function of consumer demand: more pets, more spending per pet, more replacement purchases. Future Market Insights follows this logic faithfully, projecting expansion from rising ownership, enrichment-driven spending, and durability-led product positioning. But Walmart is not simply allocating more shelf space to pet products. It is constructing an integrated services and commerce platform where pet food, supplies, pharmacy, veterinary access, and media all connect through a single customer relationship.

Consider the sequence. A Walmart+ member uses Pawp for a free virtual vet consultation. The vet recommends a dental chew. The member adds it to a recurring delivery order alongside pet food and prescriptions, fulfilled through Walmart’s store network or WFS. A Walmart Connect Sponsored Search ad influenced the brand selection at the moment of search. Scintilla’s Channel Performance data tells the supplier which stores are converting and which have out-of-stock gaps. From need identification through purchase to replenishment, the entire loop occurs within Walmart’s owned infrastructure.

That context changes how pet toys are evaluated. Suppliers selling through Walmart are operating inside a system designed to capture and retain customer lifetime value across the full spectrum of pet ownership. Walmart’s vice president of pet merchandising, Kaitlyn Shadiow, described the ambition in an October 2024 corporate announcement, positioning Walmart as a destination where pet parents access products, prescriptions, and services at everyday low prices through an omnichannel experience.

A chew toy that drives repeat purchases and complements adjacent categories (dental health, enrichment, training) carries more value to Walmart’s buyers than a novelty item with a higher initial margin but no replenishment tail. Line reviews reflect this calculus when buyers evaluate which SKUs earn continued placement.

The Fee Structure Is Signaling Exactly Where Walmart Wants Seller Investment

Walmart’s Seasonal Favorites incentive program, running from August 31, 2025, through January 31, 2026, cut referral fees by 50% on qualifying pet supply items and eliminated them entirely on qualifying toys. Details published on Walmart’s Marketplace site show the program required sellers to maintain competitive pricing (winning or matching the Buy Box price), fulfill orders in three days or fewer (either self-fulfilled or through WFS), and invest at least 4% of category GMV in Walmart Connect advertising via Sponsored Search, Brand Shops, or other formats. Sellers who fell below Walmart’s performance standards forfeited the incentive.

Those requirements are worth reading closely. The fee reduction is not a gift; it is a structured trade. Walmart subsidizes your referral cost in exchange for price competitiveness, fulfillment speed, and advertising spend. Competitive pricing protects Walmart’s price perception against Amazon and Chewy. Fast fulfillment supports the retailer’s push toward same-day and next-day delivery, which now reaches 93% of U.S. households, according to Walmart’s Q4 FY26 earnings release. And the 4% advertising threshold feeds Walmart Connect’s growth at a moment when ad revenue is expanding far faster than the underlying retail business.

Marketplace Pulse reported in November 2025 that Walmart’s advertising business was growing at six times the rate of its overall retail sales, with Walmart Connect posting 33% growth in Q3 FY26 and U.S. net sales growing in the mid-single digits. As the analysis observed, for the more than 200,000 sellers on Walmart’s marketplace, advertising is becoming mandatory rather than optional, because when ad revenue grows that much faster than sales, sellers pay more for the same visibility. Pet toy sellers who took advantage of the Seasonal Favorites fee reduction without simultaneously building a sustainable Walmart Connect strategy may find that the economics reverse quickly once the incentive window closes.

Whether a similar program returns for the second half of 2026 remains uncertain. But even if it does not, the structural logic will persist. Walmart has shown that it will use referral fee levers to steer seller behavior toward the outcomes it wants: competitive prices, fast delivery, paid advertising.

Fulfillment Speed Has Become a Category Filter, Not a Preference

Future Market Insights identifies specialty pet stores as the leading channel at roughly 41% share, with online scaling but constrained by pricing discipline challenges. This framing understates the velocity of change in how online pet purchases get to the customer. Walmart reported in its Q4 FY26 earnings that store-fulfilled delivery channels grew more than 50% year over year, with 35% of those orders delivered in under three hours. Ecommerce represented 23% of Walmart U.S. sales in Q4, a record high. Fiscal 2026 ecommerce sales exceeded $150 billion globally for the first time, per CFO John David Rainey’s comments during the earnings call.

On the 1P side, this acceleration intensifies the importance of OTIF compliance and MABD adherence. Products that miss delivery windows do not simply incur fines; they miss the fulfillment cycle that feeds Walmart’s fastest-growing sales channel. A customer searching for a dog chew toy on Walmart.com and filtering by next-day delivery sees items fulfilled through WFS or stocked in nearby stores first. An item sitting in a distribution center with a delayed inbound shipment is functionally invisible.

Marketplace sellers face a parallel squeeze. WFS sellers see a roughly 50% lift in gross merchandise volume on items tagged with Walmart Fulfilled and two-day shipping, according to Walmart’s Marketplace resources. The Seasonal Favorites program required three-day-or-faster fulfillment. For a category where most items sell between $5 and $30 at retail, the unit economics of self-fulfillment become difficult to sustain against the scale advantages of WFS, which Walmart has stated costs approximately 15% less than competing fulfillment services on average. Any seller who has not modeled WFS against their own costs for pet toy SKUs should do so before the next seasonal push. Delivery speed in this category is no longer a differentiator; it is a qualification threshold.

The Digital Shelf for Pet Toys Demands More Than Keywords

In-store, a pet toy sells on packaging appeal, planogram placement, and adjacency to complementary products. Online, it sells on search relevance, image quality, listing completeness, and the algorithmic weighting Walmart’s platform applies to items with strong content scores and fulfillment credentials. Pet toys live in both worlds simultaneously, and the content requirements differ in each.

Walmart’s Supplier One consolidation of item setup (which absorbed functions previously handled through Item 360 and NOVA) means 1P suppliers now manage product content, images, attributes, and categorization through a single interface. Listing quality scores influence search ranking on Walmart.com and the Walmart app. Pet toys present a specific content challenge in this context: the category spans durable chew toys, plush toys, interactive puzzles, rope toys, and ball launchers, each with distinct attribute requirements and search behaviors. A supplier managing 50 dog toy SKUs across multiple formats needs a systematic approach to title structure, attribute completeness, image count, and feature bullet accuracy to meet Walmart’s content scoring thresholds.

On the Marketplace side, Walmart introduced AI-powered listing tools at the 2025 Let’s Grow Marketplace Seller Summit, enabling single and bulk item setups designed to reduce time to market. But automated listing generation is only as good as the inputs. A pet toy seller who relies on generic product descriptions will produce generic listings, and generic listings lose the Buy Box to competitors with differentiated content, strong imagery, and keyword strategies informed by Scintilla’s Digital Landscapes data on how Walmart customers search within the pet category.

Scintilla In-Store, announced by Walmart Data Ventures in late February 2026, adds yet another variable. The platform gives supplier field representatives real-time inventory visibility and execution tools inside Walmart stores. What matters most to pet toy suppliers here is the connection between shelf-level data and digital campaign performance. A Walmart Connect Sponsored Products campaign on a chew toy that happens to be out of stock in a significant number of stores is spending money to generate demand that cannot convert in the physical channel. Suppliers with Scintilla access who cross-reference Channel Performance sell-through data with In-Store inventory visibility can tighten that gap in ways smaller competitors cannot.

Chew Toys Dominate Revenue, but Walmart’s Buyer Expects Portfolio Discipline

Future Market Insights highlights chew toys at 36% of category revenue, driven by consistent replacement purchasing and broad relevance across dog-owning households. Interactive, plush, rope, and ball formats complement the category but remain structured around inventory discipline and portfolio efficiency, in the report’s framing. This language aligns closely with how Walmart’s own buyers evaluate pet toy assortments.

Walmart buyers in the pet category have historically favored suppliers who demonstrate what the industry calls “good/better/best” tiering: a clear progression from value-priced core items through mid-tier options to premium differentiated products. Applied to chew toys, this means a supplier should present a portfolio where the entry-level rubber chew has a clear role distinct from a veterinarian-endorsed dental chew and a premium natural rubber option. Each tier needs to justify itself through distinct consumer targets, margin contributions, and velocity expectations. Illustrative price points in the Walmart pet aisle tend to run from roughly $6 at the value end to nearly $20 for premium formats, though specific pricing varies by brand and format.

That question of portfolio discipline becomes more pointed as Walmart expands its own private-label presence in pet. The PRO+ pet food launch demonstrated that the retailer is willing to compete directly in premium segments once ceded to national brands. In pet toys, Walmart’s private-label efforts are less visible than in food, but the Vibrant Life brand already occupies shelf space in the value tier. Suppliers whose product lines overlap heavily with Vibrant Life’s positioning without offering material differentiation in durability, safety certification, or consumer-recognizable brand equity face a shrinking competitive window.

The response is not to flee from the value tier but to ensure that every SKU in a Walmart assortment has a defensible reason for its placement. Suppliers entering line reviews with data from Scintilla’s Shopper Behavior module can make a case that goes beyond velocity to address which consumer segments are purchasing their products, at what frequency, and with what basket adjacencies.

The Forecast That Matters Is Not the Global One

A $9.3 billion global pet toy market by 2036 is a useful framing for investors and manufacturers planning production capacity. The supplier sitting in a Bentonville conference room presenting a line review needs a different kind of forecast, and so does the Marketplace seller optimizing a Walmart Connect campaign on a $12 dog rope toy. The projection that matters is of Walmart’s own expectations: how fast it will push fulfillment speed requirements, how aggressively it will build its pet services platform to capture adjacent spending, how deeply Walmart Connect’s advertising load will penetrate the category, and how tightly Scintilla’s data tools will bind execution to commercial outcomes.

Walmart’s fiscal 2026 results paint that picture clearly. U.S. ecommerce grew 27%. Walmart Connect advertising revenue grew 41%. Same-day delivery reached 93% of U.S. households, and the Marketplace continued to widen assortment across general merchandise categories. The Q4 earnings release described sales momentum driven by digital-led customer transactions and broad-based share gains.

Pet toy suppliers who read the FMI forecast and see comfortable long-term growth should also read Walmart’s earnings and see what comfortable actually costs: fulfillment that qualifies you for visibility, advertising spend that earns you search placement, content that meets scoring thresholds, and data-informed execution that connects the shelf to the screen. The global market will indeed grow. Whether your business captures that growth through Walmart depends on how well it is built for the retailer’s version of the category, where repeat-purchase products are the connective tissue of an integrated commerce platform and every data point from the shelf to the search bar feeds back into the system that decides which products customers see.

Winning With Walmart

Winning With Walmart is an independent platform for suppliers, sellers, solution providers, and industry experts.

Articles are developed by staff editors, contributing experts, and trusted partners.

Some are researched and drafted with the assistance of AI tools and are reviewed, fact-checked, and edited by Winning With Walmart editors before publication.

Editorial judgment, sourcing decisions, and final approval rest with the publication's human editors in every case.

We are committed to accuracy and fairness. If you believe this article contains an error, we welcome your feedback.